All podcasts / Invest Like the Best / Summary

Nick Kokonas - Know What You Are Selling (REPLAY)

2025-12-30 - 76 min - source - Read full transcript

Patrick O'Shaughnessy (host)Nick Kokonas

Key insights

Most businesses, restaurants especially, are actually selling several distinct products bundled into one undifferentiated offer, and simply naming and selling each one separately unlocks revenue without changing costs.

Using Gramercy Tavern as the example, Kokonas counts eight separate things being sold under one roof - the bar, casual dining, a-la-carte, two tasting menus, wine pairings, private dining, and merchandise - yet the restaurant only ever asks a guest 'are you showing up.' Segmenting and selling each experience separately, he argues, is how you sell 100 tasting menus with certainty on a Saturday instead of hoping 4% of walk-ins opt in.

know-what-youre-selling

Any business that sells access to a specific time slot should price that slot dynamically, because demand is never flat across the week.

Kokonas generalizes from options theory: restaurants, salons, dentists, and personal trainers all have predictably uneven demand (Saturday night versus Tuesday at 6am) yet almost none of them price for it. He argues the tools for dynamic pricing already exist for hard goods (Amazon, Shopify) and will inevitably extend to time-slotted services.

dynamic-pricing-and-behavioral-economics

Ticketed, prepaid restaurant reservations function like expiring options and were costing Alinea over a million dollars a year in unrealized revenue before Tock existed.

Kokonas found guests routinely lied about party size to secure a table, and the restaurant routinely lied back about table availability to avoid losing bookings, both of which produced empty seats or forgone revenue that compounded across hundreds of nights a year. Selling tickets with a deposit, the way concerts and sports do, removed both incentives to lie.

dynamic-pricing-and-behavioral-economics

A slim statistical edge, applied to a high volume of independent decisions, is a more repeatable path to wealth than trying to be right most of the time.

Drawing on his background as a derivatives trader, Kokonas frames his own version of the casino's edge: being wrong nearly half the time is fine if you make enough independent, measurable decisions and the edge is real, and treating each decision's outcome as data rather than a referendum on self-worth is what lets a business keep making decisions instead of freezing up after failures.

founder-decision-making

Deliberately choosing your first customers, and just as deliberately refusing customers before you can serve them well, determines a business's long-term trajectory.

Tock targeted high-end restaurants first (the 'Tesla approach') because they could prove clear ROI and tolerate risk, rather than racing competitors to give away a free, undifferentiated product to price-sensitive customers. Kokonas also turned away restaurants that wanted to sign up before Tock had features they needed, judging that serving them poorly would have been worse than losing the deal.

founder-decision-making

Prepaying suppliers can unlock steep discounts by eliminating the supplier's own risk, not just by improving the buyer's cash position.

Kokonas called a beef vendor and offered to prepay four months of a $300,000 order; the vendor cut the price from $34 to $18 a pound because prepayment removed the vendor's exposure to unsold, spoiling dry-aged beef past its 35-day sell window. He generalizes this as evidence that most restaurants treat float purely as cash-management, missing a much larger margin lever.

restaurant-business-economics

Self-publishing is a far better business than working with a traditional publisher once you already have an audience, because standard publishing contracts hide thin actual printing costs.

Kokonas describes calling Chinese printers directly and finding a $50 retail book costs about $2 to print, while typical publisher terms pay the author roughly 10% of cover price, require a 5,000-copy self-order, and offer an advance that Kokonas argues represents real risk-free profit for the publisher. His group now publishes its own books and sold $120,000 of them in a single week, at higher margins than the restaurants themselves.

restaurant-business-economics

Capturing a customer's email, not their phone number, is the single highest-leverage piece of data a service business can collect, and most booking software deliberately withholds it from the business.

Kokonas calls this 'stranger danger': without an email identifier, a restaurant has no way to recognize a repeat guest, personalize their experience, or build lookalike audiences on Facebook and Instagram. He argues incumbent booking platforms resist surfacing this data because owning the customer relationship, not the restaurant, is how they monetize.

know-what-youre-selling

Recognizing a low-probability, high-severity risk early, and acting on it before it's socially acceptable to do so, requires tolerating looking irrational to your own team.

Kokonas describes instituting temperature checks, mask wearing, and mandatory hand-washing at his restaurants two and a half weeks before Chicago's shutdown, based on reading officials' visible panic on TV rather than their public reassurances. He was initially seen as 'unhinged' by staff, and only enforced compliance by threatening termination once he judged the stakes were existential.

covid-crisis-response

Because Tock was cloud-based and already built around time-slotted, dynamically priced inventory, it could pivot an entire restaurant group to carryout in about a week when COVID hit.

Twenty designers and engineers worked around the clock to launch a carryout product for Canlis in Seattle, then for Alinea itself, which began selling $35 beef Wellingtons three days after Chicago's shutdown and reached $1,000 nightly carryout sales within a week. Tock then undercut DoorDash-style delivery apps' 20-30% commissions with a flat 3% fee, arguing the pandemic exposed how unsustainable that take rate was once delivery became restaurants' only revenue source rather than supplemental income.

covid-crisis-response

Media referenced

Picasso documentary from the 1920s - movie - Kokonas made Grant Achatz watch a 1920s film of Picasso painting to make the case for showing process as promotion; it directly inspired Alinea's tableside plating-on-the-table dessert.
Chef's Table - show - Netflix put the restaurant's latex table-plating dessert on Los Angeles billboards to promote the show, cited as evidence the idea became a cultural touchstone.
Why We Are Self-Publishing the Aviary Book - article - Kokonas's own Medium post laying out the terms publishers offered his group, used to argue that publishing contracts are structured to hide thin printing costs from authors.

Companies

Alinea - Kokonas's Michelin three-star restaurant, run as a business first; the site of the ticketing, dynamic pricing, and process-as-art experiments discussed throughout.
Next - The second restaurant Kokonas and Grant Achatz built, structured explicitly as theater with a changing menu; its 2011 launch is where ticketed dining first proved itself, selling $562,000 in tickets on day one.
The Aviary - Third restaurant in the group, referenced as part of the trio (Alinea, Next, The Aviary) that Kokonas co-founded and that anchors the Tock business.
Tock - Kokonas's reservation, ticketing, and payments software company, built to fix what he saw as broken incentives in restaurant booking software; the episode's throughline.
OpenTable - Used as the foil throughout: a reservations business that intermediates the restaurant-diner relationship and monetizes per-diner without giving restaurants ownership of their own customer data.
Resy - Named alongside OpenTable and Reserve as an existing reservations competitor Kokonas read about in a Wall Street Journal article that prompted his viral blog post on ticketing.
Yelp - Cited as the acquirer of a waitlist-app company for about $40 million, used by Kokonas as an example of underbuilt, underexecuted ideas getting overvalued.
DoorDash - Referenced as a third-party delivery platform charging restaurants 20-30% commissions; Tock undercut this with a flat 3% fee during COVID, framed as an existential threat to the delivery-app model once it became restaurants' primary revenue source.
Google - Tock's early engineering talent came from Google; Brian Fitzpatrick, then head of Google Chicago, left to co-found Tock with Kokonas after hearing him give a talk on dynamic pricing.
Gramercy Tavern - Used as the extended case study for how a single restaurant is actually selling eight distinct products (bar, casual dining, a-la-carte, two tasting menus, wine pairings, private dining, merchandise) without differentiating the offer to customers.
Canlis - Seattle restaurant that asked Tock to help it pivot to carryout at the start of COVID, becoming the first live test of Tock's rapid pivot to a takeout and delivery product.
Origin Ventures - Jason Helzer's firm; Helzer, who Kokonas met as a fellow judge at a University of Chicago Booth New Venture Challenge, became Tock's first outside investor with a term sheet negotiated in a single meeting.

Techniques and frameworks

Own something, make decisions with outcomes, be right 51% of the time, repeat - Kokonas's opening framework for wealth creation, drawn from his Greek immigrant family and his time as a derivatives trader: ownership plus high-volume decision-making with even a slim statistical edge compounds like a casino's house edge.
Dynamic and variable pricing for time-slotted businesses - Kokonas's generalization from options theory: any business that sells access to a specific time slot (restaurants, salons, dentists, personal trainers) should price that slot dynamically, since demand is never flat across the week.
Ticketing and prepaid deposits as a restaurant business model - Selling restaurant seats like theater or concert tickets, sometimes with dynamic pricing, to eliminate no-shows and phantom party-size padding, both of which Kokonas calculated were costing Alinea over $1 million a year before Tock existed.
Know what you're selling - Kokonas's core thesis: most businesses (restaurants especially) sell several distinct experiences bundled as one undifferentiated offer, and naming and selling each experience separately unlocks revenue without changing costs.
Stranger danger / email as unique customer identifier - Kokonas's insistence on capturing a customer's email (not phone number) as the durable identifier needed to avoid treating every walk-in diner as an anonymous stranger, enabling remarketing and cross-restaurant recognition.
Prepaying vendors to buy at a discount - Kokonas called major food vendors and offered to prepay months of purchases upfront; a beef supplier cut the price in half because prepayment eliminated the vendor's own spoilage risk from unsold aged product.

Summary

This is a replay of Patrick O'Shaughnessy's November 2020 Founder's Field Guide conversation with Nick Kokonas, the philosophy-major-turned-derivatives-trader who co-founded Alinea, Next, and The Aviary and built the reservations and payments company Tock. The conversation opens with Kokonas unpacking his own three-part formula for wealth creation - own something, make lots of decisions that have measurable outcomes, and be right just slightly more than half the time, repeated at volume - a framework he traces to growing up in a Greek immigrant family in Chicago and later trading derivatives, where the goal was never to be right most of the time but to run the house's edge across enough independent bets.

The bulk of the episode is a granular tour of how Kokonas rebuilt restaurant economics around a single idea: know what you're selling, then actually sell it. Using Gramercy Tavern as a case study, he shows that a single restaurant is really selling eight distinct products (bar seating, casual dining, a-la-carte, two tasting menus, wine pairings, private dining, and merchandise) but almost never differentiates the offer to a guest before they arrive. This connects to his broader argument, carried over from his trading background, that any time-slotted business should price dynamically, and that ticketed, prepaid reservations function like expiring options - eliminating the mutual lying between restaurants and guests over table sizes and availability that was costing Alinea over a million dollars a year before Tock existed. He walks through Next's 2011 launch, where ticketed dining sold $562,000 on day one despite near-universal skepticism from his own team and from VCs who insisted he needed a cheap, freemium, B2C strategy instead of starting with high-end restaurants that could prove the model.

Several tangents flesh out the same "know what you're selling" thesis in adjacent domains. Kokonas describes calling suppliers directly to prepay for goods months in advance, discovering that a beef vendor would cut prices in half because prepayment eliminated the vendor's own risk of spoiled, unsold dry-aged product - a lever he argues most restaurants ignore because they treat float purely as a cash-management tool. He makes a similar case for self-publishing: after learning that a $50 book costs roughly $2 to print, he began publishing his own group's books rather than accepting standard contracts that pay authors around 10% of cover price, and now runs a materially better-margin business than the restaurants themselves. Throughout, he repeats a related principle he calls "stranger danger": most restaurants have no way to identify a repeat customer because they never capture an email address, the durable identifier that lets any business remarket, personalize, and build lookalike audiences the way Amazon or Netflix do.

The episode closes with an account of Tock's response to COVID, which Kokonas frames as a direct extension of the same probabilistic-thinking training that shaped his trading and restaurant careers. He describes recognizing the pandemic as a low-probability but existential risk weeks before Chicago's shutdown, instituting safety protocols that made him look "unhinged" to his own staff, and then leading a week-long sprint to rebuild Tock into a carryout and delivery platform - first for Canlis in Seattle, then for his own restaurants, which went from $35 beef Wellingtons to $1,000 nightly carryout sales within days. He positions Tock's flat 3% take rate as a direct challenge to third-party delivery apps charging 20-30%, arguing that rate only survived as long as delivery was supplemental restaurant revenue rather than a primary lifeline. The conversation ends, as the original Founder's Field Guide episodes did, with Patrick's closing question about the kindest thing anyone has done for Kokonas, prompting a story about an employee who returned a stolen restaurant napkin embedded in the handle of a hand-forged knife.

Notable Quotes

"Own something, make lots of decisions that have outcomes, try to be right 51% of the time, do that often and repeat." - Nick Kokonas

"Know what you're selling and then actually sell it, which sounds incredibly obvious. It's so stupid. I'm telling you what, there should be a business course on that." - Nick Kokonas

"People can't buy what you don't sell." - Nick Kokonas

"I like businesses that are hard because if I can figure them out... I just go like, well, people are full of shit. They're defending their position." - Nick Kokonas

"The concept of the phrase burn in a startup is just the worst word in the world because I'm not burning money, I'm investing it." - Nick Kokonas