All podcasts / People I (Mostly) Admire / Summary

103. Rick Rubin on How to Make Something Great (Update)

2025-08-23 - 59 min - source - Read full transcript

Steve Levitt (host)Rick Rubin

Key insights

Being a music producer is structurally closer to being a film director than to what 'producer' means in most other industries.

Rubin says producers run the full spectrum a director's job covers: casting/hiring musicians, technical decisions, editing, and helping shape the material itself. Individual producers specialize wildly, from beat-makers to pop specialists to storyboard-everything Hitchcock types, and Rubin says he came to it as 'a professional fan' rather than through engineering or performing.

creative-process

The 'Walk This Way' collaboration with Run DMC and Aerosmith was engineered as a legitimizing demonstration, not a commercial bet.

In the mid-1980s the recording industry didn't treat hip-hop as music at all. Rubin picked a familiar, non-melodic-phrased rock song specifically so mainstream listeners would hear rap's cadence inside something they already accepted as music and realize, in his words, 'I always knew what rap music was, I just didn't know I knew it.' He says he never expected it to be a hit, only a proof of concept.

simplicity-hidden-in-plain-sight

Rubin chose Johnny Cash specifically to stress-test whether his creative approach was general, not because Cash needed a hit.

After early success working exclusively with young artists his own age, Rubin deliberately sought someone experienced, not currently doing their best work, to see if the same naive, no-prior-experience method would transfer to a veteran. Johnny Cash, then playing 200-seat dinner theaters in Orange County, was the first name that came to mind because of his mythological stature even in his own diminished view of himself.

creative-process

The most powerful recordings are often the informal, undocumented byproducts of a process, not the takes made when everyone knew they were 'making the record.'

Rubin recorded Cash playing roughly a hundred songs alone on guitar in his living room purely to catalog material, with no intention of releasing it. Sessions afterward with the world's best studio bands never sounded as interesting as those unguarded living-room takes, which became the actual basis of the albums.

creative-process

Outcomes are unpredictable and mostly outside a creator's control, so the only sound strategy is to make the best thing possible and let go of what happens next.

Rubin cites releasing an album the day of 9/11 as an example of how marketing, distribution, timing, and radio access can override even great work, none of which the maker controls. He extends this to hit songs that started as throwaway B-sides: 'We don't know what's good. We don't know what's big... If we make something and we get excited about it, that's the best we can do.'

detachment-from-outcome

Rubin's personal test for whether a piece of work is finished is a single trusted friend's excited reaction, not audience research or commercial projection.

He says if he's excited to show something to one friend whose taste he respects, it's ready. Levitt connects this to his own experience writing Freakonomics with Stephen Dubner: they abandoned a rule-bound, thesis-driven outline in a Las Vegas hotel room and decided to just write a book that was fun, assuming almost no one would read it, and it became a commercial hit.

detachment-from-outcome

Creative work moves through distinct phases (seed, experimentation, craft, completion) that require opposite handling, and misapplying open-ended rules to the completion phase is what made finishing hardest for Rubin.

He treated completion with the same infinite, free-play rules as the early seed and experimentation phases for most of his career, believing a deadline would always hurt the work. Writing The Creative Act taught him a deadline only undermines work at the beginning; once the work's identity is locked in and only refinement remains, a deadline helps rather than hurts.

creative-process

Deep expertise can blind people to breakthroughs that a naive or 'ruleless' approach can see, because experts confuse socially accepted convention with the actual rules of the game.

Rubin recounts crying while watching a documentary about AlphaGo's win over the world Go champion: the computer's decisive move looked like a mistake to commentators and made the grandmaster leave the table, not because it broke the rules of Go but because no human had ever played that way. Rubin argues creative breakthroughs work the same way: knowing what's 'impossible' actively prevents you from doing the impossible.

creative-confidence

Meditation trained Rubin to register an emotional or somatic signal before any intellectual explanation of it arrives.

He learned Transcendental Meditation at 14 after a pediatrician linked his neck pain to stress, and cites The Beatles' association with meditation as what made him receptive to it as a teenager. He describes creative judgment as feeling pulled toward or pushed away from something in the body first, with rational understanding of why only coming afterward.

meditation-and-somatic-awareness

Reframing a personal failure as something happening to a character in a movie creates enough emotional distance to keep acting instead of freezing inside the pain.

Rubin describes consciously 'zooming out' during setbacks to watch himself the way he'd watch a protagonist on screen, asking 'how does our hero get out of this' rather than staying inside the immediate distress, which he frames as a repeatable technique rather than a one-off coping trick.

meditation-and-somatic-awareness

Creativity is a universal birthright that most people are talked out of, not a rare trait some people simply lack.

Levitt illustrates this with a first-year Ph.D. student at the University of Chicago who insisted he 'wasn't very creative' after working on a project an advisor had assigned him; told to spend a week on his own ideas instead, he returned with two research-paper-worthy ideas and never stopped generating them, later earning tenure at a top law school. Rubin's book opens on the same claim: creativity is 'a fundamental aspect of being human,' not a scarce talent.

creative-confidence

Books referenced

The Creative Act: A Way of Being - Rick Rubin - Rubin's book of creative philosophy, the subject of most of the interview; eight years and roughly a thousand pages of notes distilled into 78 short areas of thought.
The Wave Code: The Timeless Art of Vibe Coding - Rick Rubin - Mentioned in the closing 2025 update segment as Rubin's newest project, an introduction to vibe coding and interactive art that he says is based on Laozi's Dao De Jing.

Media referenced

AlphaGo (Google documentary) - movie - Rubin describes watching this documentary about the AlphaGo vs. world-champion Go match and being moved to tears by the machine's rule-breaking winning move, using it as a parable for how real creative breakthroughs happen.
Tetragrammaton - podcast - Rubin's own interview podcast; he mentions interviewing Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails on it and references it as an ongoing project.
"Hurt" music video (Johnny Cash) - other - Directed by Mark Romanek; discussed at length as the visual counterpart to the Cash recording of the Nine Inch Nails song, filmed at Cash's real home and the closed House of Cash museum shortly before his death.
Freakonomics (book) - other - Levitt references writing this book with Stephen Dubner as his own example of abandoning a rule-bound outline in favor of writing something fun, which then became a commercial success neither of them expected.

Companies

Def Jam Records - Founded by Rubin out of his NYU dorm room (Weinstein Hall) after producing 'It's Yours' by T La Rock and Jazzy Jay; grew via LL Cool J and a partnership with Russell Simmons.
MTV - Named Rubin the most important music producer of the last 20 years in 2007, per the host's introduction.
Freakonomics Radio Network - Parent network of People I (Mostly) Admire; also produces Freakonomics Radio and The Economics of Everyday Things.
Substack - Where Rubin says he and his team publish weekly experiential practices based on the philosophy in The Creative Act.

Techniques and frameworks

Seed, experimentation, craft, and completion phases - Rubin's four-stage model of the creative process, each with different rules; he explains he used to treat the completion phase with the same open-ended free play as the seed phase, which was a mistake, since a deadline only hurts the work early on and helps once the piece's identity is settled.
The one-friend test - Rubin's personal standard for knowing a piece is finished: if he is excited to play it for one friend whose taste he trusts, it's ready, regardless of anticipated commercial or audience reaction.
Detachment from outcome - Rubin's operating principle that success is never predictable or controllable (marketing, distribution, timing, luck all sit outside the maker's control, illustrated by an album he released the day of 9/11), so the only sound strategy is to make the best possible thing and let go of the result.
Transcendental Meditation - Rubin learned TM at 14 after his pediatrician suggested it for stress-related neck pain; he describes it as training him to feel emotional pulls toward or away from something in his body before he can explain them intellectually.
Zooming out to spectator distance from failure - Rubin's reframe for setbacks: imagine the bad moment happening to a character in a movie you're watching, which creates enough distance to ask 'how does our hero get out of this' instead of staying inside the pain.

Summary

This is an encore/update airing of one of host Steve Levitt's favorite episodes: a 2023 conversation with music producer Rick Rubin, closed out with a short new voice-memo update from Rubin about his current project. Rubin, who started Def Jam Records out of his NYU dorm room and went on to produce artists from Run DMC and LL Cool J to Metallica, Jay-Z, Adele, and Johnny Cash, was promoting his book The Creative Act: A Way of Being at the time of the original interview. Levitt opens by admitting he knew almost nothing about the music industry or Rubin going in, and was surprised to find the book was not a memoir but a work of creative philosophy that hit him personally.

The first half traces Rubin's origin story in hip-hop: as a white NYU student running a label out of his dorm, he produced early hits for T La Rock and Jazzy Jay and LL Cool J before Russell Simmons brought him in to produce Run DMC's Raising Hell. Rubin explains the reasoning behind pairing Run DMC with Aerosmith's "Walk This Way," a decision made specifically to demonstrate that rap was music at all, at a time when the recording industry, radio, and most listeners didn't recognize it as such. He describes it as a deliberate, low-stakes proof of concept, not a commercial bet, and one that worked essentially overnight. The conversation then turns to how Rubin later found Johnny Cash, then playing dinner theaters in Orange County well past what most people considered his prime, as a way to test whether his production method (developed entirely with young artists) generalized to a veteran performer. The resulting living-room demo sessions, recorded with no intention of release, became the foundation of Cash's late-career American Recordings albums, including the Nine Inch Nails cover "Hurt," whose lyrics and Mark Romanek-directed video Rubin discusses as one of the most emotionally devastating pieces he's ever been part of.

The second half is a close reading of The Creative Act itself. Rubin describes an eight-year process of "reverse engineering" what actually works in the studio, distilled from roughly a thousand pages of notes into 78 short areas of thought, deliberately avoiding a memoir format so publishers who wanted stories about Jay-Z and Johnny Cash had to accept the book he actually wanted to write or pass. He lays out a four-phase model of creativity (seed, experimentation, craft, completion) and explains that deadlines, which he long believed only hurt open-ended creative work, actually help once a piece is in its completion phase. Levitt connects several of Rubin's ideas to his own life, including his experience feeling like the "dumbest person in the room" during his economics Ph.D. at MIT and the decision he and Stephen Dubner made to abandon a rule-bound outline and just write Freakonomics for fun.

A recurring thread is Rubin's insistence that outcomes are neither predictable nor controllable, illustrated by an album he released the day of 9/11 and by the long history of B-side songs becoming bigger hits than their intended A-sides. His personal readiness test for finished work is simply whether he's excited to play it for one trusted friend. The conversation closes on Rubin's spiritual grounding: he learned Transcendental Meditation at 14 (inspired partly by knowing the Beatles meditated), which he describes as training him to register emotional pulls in his body before he can explain them intellectually, and a reframing technique of watching his own setbacks the way he'd watch a character's setback in a movie, to create distance from the pain. He connects this to a documentary about AlphaGo's win over the world Go champion, which moved him to tears because the machine's rule-bending winning move succeeded precisely because it wasn't burdened by centuries of "accepted" human strategy.

In the closing 2025 update segment, Levitt shares a voice memo Rubin sent describing his newest project, a book on "vibe coding" he says is inspired by Laozi's Dao De Jing, alongside weekly Substack practices tied to The Creative Act's philosophy and expansion of his Tetragrammaton podcast platform. Levitt also uses the episode's outro to restate the book's central claim, that creativity is a birthright rather than a rare gift, telling the story of a University of Chicago Ph.D. student who believed he wasn't creative until given a week and permission to generate his own research ideas.

Notable Quotes

"The ideas in the book are like smoke. They're very difficult to grasp. Stuff that when you read it, you feel like you already know it, but it's difficult to hold onto." - Rick Rubin

"If we make something and we get excited about it, that's the best we can do. And to think past that undermines the whole thing." - Rick Rubin

"Creativity is not a rare ability. It's not difficult to access. Creativity is a fundamental aspect of being human. It's our birthright and it's for all of us." - Rick Rubin (as read by Steve Levitt)

"The computer didn't win because it was smarter than the man. The computer knew less... You have to believe in something that's impossible to allow it to come into existence." - Rick Rubin